Introduction

In today's dynamic financial landscape, private equity fundraising plays a vital role in fuelling economic growth, supporting innovation, and driving business expansion. However, the cost of capital is a crucial factor influencing investment decisions. When interest rates rise, private equity funds face a unique set of challenges that can impact their fundraising efforts. This article explores the effect of high interest rates on private equity fundraising, highlighting the potential implications for fund managers and investors, and providing insights into strategies to navigate these challenges while maximizing opportunities.

Understanding the Relationship between Interest Rates and Private Equity Fundraising:

Interest rates are one of the most important factors that investors consider when making investment decisions. When interest rates are low, investors are more likely to invest in riskier assets, such as private equity, because the potential returns are higher. This is because the cost of borrowing money is lower, so investors can afford to take on more risk. However, when interest rates rise, investors become more risk-averse and are less likely to invest in private equity. This is because the cost of borrowing money is higher, so the potential returns need to be higher to justify the risk. As a result, fundraising for private equity funds tends to slow down when interest rates rise.

We can specifically highlight the correlation between interest rates and fund performance as one important factor in this equation and specifically given the strong negative correlation for Private Equity, this raises questions on how investors are allocating funds in this environment. The reason behind this negative correlation is in some ways simple.

When interest rates are low, private equity funds tend to perform well because they can borrow money at a lower cost and invest in riskier assets. However, when interest rates rise, private equity funds tend to perform worse because the cost of borrowing money is higher, and the potential returns are lower. This is because the value of assets held by private equity funds is often linked to interest rates. For example, if interest rates rise, the value of debt-laden companies will fall, which can hurt the performance of the funds that own these companies. Interest rate sensitivity can obviously vary from fund to fund but empirically it is higher in those funds who use higher leverage for buyouts and those that utilise facilities at different levels of the fund structure.

Additionally, interest rate fluctuations can also have a significant impact on investor sentiment in those looking to allocate to PE. When interest rates are low, investors are more likely to be optimistic about the future and are more likely to invest in PE as they seek higher returns, and the cost of capital is low. However, when interest rates rise, investors become more pessimistic about the future and are less likely to invest in asset classes where like Private Funds. This is because interest rate fluctuations can signal changes in the overall economic outlook. For example, if interest rates rise sharply, it could be a sign that the economy is headed for a recession. This inevitably impacts demand for PE as investors feel less comfortable that funds will perform in a weak economy as their underlying companies struggle for revenue growth.

Challenges Faced by Private Equity Funds in a High Interest Rate Environment:

As interest rates rise, the cost of capital for private equity funds also rises, again linked to underlying company debt burden. As a result, the higher cost of debt can have a significant impact on the return expectations of private equity funds. For example, if a private equity fund expects to generate a 10% return on its investments, but the cost of debt rises from 5% to 7%, then the fund's return expectations will fall to 7%. This is because the fund will need to earn more money on its investments to cover the higher cost of debt.

Rises in rates can also lead to extended fundraising timelines and potential liquidity constraints because investors consider their options and look to stay on the side-lines as they wait for a more stable environment. As a result, funds spend more time fundraising and using valuable dealmaker time on investor roadshows and meetings which in turn leads to less time to make those crucial deals. Additionally, the increase in interest rates can make it more difficult for private equity funds to raise money from debt markets, which can lead to liquidity constraints.

Strategies for Successfully Navigating High Interest Rates:

In a high interest rate environment, funds may need to focus on raising capital from yield-hungry institutional investors and consider providing income from investments through return of capital. These investors are typically looking for assets that can generate attractive returns, even in a rising interest rate environment. As a result, private equity funds may need to emphasize the yield potential of their investments and the value creation potential of their investment strategies.

In a crowded and competitive market, funds need to differentiate themselves from their competitors and from alternatives. By focusing on sectors and geographies that are expected to thrive in a rising interest rate environment or they can emphasize their value creation potential. A clear plan for how they will generate returns for their investors is crucial as they move into the fundraising process and not to just rely on the typical humdrum presentation.

Sectors that are characterized by strong cash flow generation, such as healthcare and utilities, are typically more resilient to rising interest rates. Additionally, geographies with strong economic fundamentals, such as the United States and Europe, are typically more resilient and so funds plying their trade in these areas may be better placed in the current environment and have more success than those in other sectors and geographies.

Funds might also look to optimize their capital structure and explore alternative financing options to mitigate the impact of rising interest rates. By using more equity and less debt in their financing structures they can mitigate some of the effects of high rates. Equally, alternative financing options become more attractive, such as mezzanine debt or preferred equity as these can help reduce the cost of capital. Conversely, if rates were to reduce, funds may be saddled with high-cost financing that impacts overall returns but that is less flexible than variable rate debt facilities.

Finally, funds may need to develop more robust risk management frameworks to mitigate interest rate risk and develop scenario planning to try to foresee economic swings that lead to rate changes.

Maximizing Opportunities in a High Interest Rate Environment:

In a high interest rate environment, there may be distressed asset opportunities arising as companies struggle to meet their debt obligations. Funds can capitalize on these opportunities by acquiring distressed assets at a discount and then implementing operational improvements to drive value creation. This happened a lot in 2008-2009 where companies struggled for credit and those PE vintages that were lucky enough to have dry powder, picked up assets at discounts to their pre-financial crises’ valuations. PE funds then use the implementation of operational improvements, such as reducing costs and improving efficiency, to improve the company's financial performance. Funds can end up generating far better returns than would have been the case in normal conditions.

One thing that remains is that PE funds need to be more active in their portfolio management. This means regularly reviewing their investments and adjusting as needed. Funds may need to sell investments that are no longer performing well or that are exposed to too much risk, and they will need to watch closely for signs of distress in the portfolio. Additionally, the fund may need to pivot to sectors or geographies that are expected to perform better in the current environment as long as their strategy allows it. By actively managing their portfolios, private equity funds can enhance their returns and reduce their risk.

Funds may need to explore partnerships and co-investment opportunities. This can help to reduce the cost of capital and increase the scale of their investments. Funds are increasingly looking to secondary deals to negate the need to sell portfolios early or in unfavourable market conditions. Some are looking for strategic partners that not only provide secondary buyout capital for current portfolios but the promise of future capital for fundraising. These partnerships can be very fruitful for both sides.

Investor Perspective: Assessing the Risks and Rewards:

In the current environment Limited Partners (LPs) need to be more careful when evaluating risk-adjusted returns. This means looking at more than just the potential return of an investment, but also the risk involved and weighing up the alternatives in their investment universe. As the cost of capital increases, more emphasis is placed on the need to find high-quality risk-adjusted returns rather than allocating capital as one has in the past and hoping that it does well. LPs who are risk averse tend to do this worst as they retrench to the managers, they know rather than evaluating them on a level playing field and considering all factors.

By considering the whole universe and different strategies available LPs can add portfolio diversification into their metrics and this is an important strategy for mitigating risk in any investment environment, but it is especially important in a high interest rate environment. This is because a diversified portfolio is less likely to be affected by changes in a single strategy or market. Diversification of a portfolio can be achieved in a number of ways, such as investing in different strategies, different geographies or industries and by considering the correlation of strategies.

While portfolio diversification is important to most LPs, due diligence is crucial to all. Monitoring managers and keeping on top of reports is so important in conditions that change regularly. This includes reviewing the investment manager's performance, the investment strategy, and the target market. Due diligence and monitoring are essential for investors who want to make informed investment decisions and can contribute to decreasing the risk of a portfolio overall.

Conclusion:

The effect of high interest rates on private equity fundraising is a complex and multi-faceted issue. While rising interest rates present challenges, they also create opportunities for fund managers and investors who adapt their strategies effectively. Successful navigation of this environment requires a comprehensive understanding of the levers at play in particular market areas, a robust risk management approach, and an ability to identify and capitalize on opportunities unique to the changing market conditions. By proactively addressing these challenges and leveraging innovative strategies, private equity funds can continue to attract capital and deliver superior returns for their investors in a high interest rate environment.

‍